Mammals

Horse Gait: 1878 Photos Proved Painters Wrong

The real beat counts and speeds behind each horse gait, the 1878 trip-wire photos that proved centuries of paintings wrong, and why horses switch gaits exactly when they do.

Last updated: 2026-09-23

A strip of twelve sequential 1878 photographs by Eadweard Muybridge showing the racehorse Sallie Gardner galloping past a row of trip-wire cameras at Stanford's Palo Alto track
Photo: Eadweard Muybridge, public domain

Core summary

A horse gait is defined by two measurable things, how many beats occur in one stride and which leg lands in what order, and only four gaits, the walk, trot, canter, and gallop, occur naturally in almost every breed. In 1878, photographer Eadweard Muybridge settled a genuine scientific dispute for his patron Leland Stanford by lining up 12 trip-wire cameras at a racetrack and photographing a galloping mare named Sallie Gardner: the images proved all four hooves do leave the ground at once, but with the legs gathered underneath the body, not stretched out fore and aft as centuries of paintings had shown. A 2004 study in the Journal of Experimental Biology found that horses switch from walking to trotting at almost the same dimensionless speed threshold regardless of body size, the exact point where trotting stops costing more energy than walking, and the AQHA-recognized world record for a quarter-mile sprint, run in 20.274 seconds by First Moonflash in 2009, still stood unbroken as of 2026.

What actually defines a gait

A gait is defined by two things anyone can count on a slow-motion video: how many beats occur in one full stride, meaning how many separate times a hoof strikes the ground before the pattern repeats, and which leg moves in what order. A four-beat gait plants each hoof down on its own. A two-beat gait lands hooves in matched pairs. Montana State University's equine extension program lists four gaits that show up naturally in almost every breed without any training at all: the walk, the trot, the canter, and the gallop.

A smaller group of acquired or ambling gaits, among them the rack, the running walk, the fox trot, and the tölt, appears only in specific breeds, and a horse's build, shoulder angle, back length, leg proportions, decides how easily a given gait comes, or whether it's possible at all. None of this is decorative terminology. A horse's beat pattern and footfall sequence change its balance, its top speed, and how comfortable it is to ride, which is exactly why breeders and riders have argued about gait mechanics for centuries, long before anyone had a way to actually check who was right. Limb proportions drive locomotion in far smaller animals too; a housecat's standing jump tracks relative hind-leg length more closely than it tracks muscle mass, the same basic principle at a very different scale.

The four natural gaits, by the numbers

Each of the four natural gaits has its own beat count, footfall order, and speed range, distinct enough that most riders can identify one within a few strides:

GaitBeatsFootfall patternTypical speed
Walk4Each hoof lands separately; two or three stay on the ground at all times3.5 to 5 mph
Trot2Diagonal front-and-hind pairs land together7 to 10 mph, faster extended
Canter3One hind leg, then the opposite diagonal pair, then the leading foreleg6 to 10 mph
Gallop4Same order as the canter, but each diagonal pair separates into two beats12 to 20+ mph, far higher in sprints

Two things fall out of that pattern. The walk never has a moment when every hoof is airborne, which is why it's the only gait a horse can hold indefinitely without tiring. And the gallop's four beats aren't evenly spaced: the split between the two halves of each diagonal pair is what actually produces the airborne moment that centuries of painters got wrong, covered in detail below.

The 1878 photographs that proved painters wrong

For centuries, painters showed a galloping horse with its front legs stretched forward and its back legs stretched back at the same moment, all four hooves off the ground in a pose closer to a leaping squirrel than anything a horse's skeleton can produce. Leland Stanford, the railroad baron, former California governor, and horse breeder who raced both Standardbred trotters and Thoroughbred runners, became convinced from watching his own horses that painters had it backward, and he wanted a photograph to settle the question.

Stanford hired photographer Eadweard Muybridge in 1872, and it took most of the decade to get a usable result; an 1873 attempt produced only a blurry smear of legs. By 1878, Muybridge had built an electrical trip-wire shutter system and lined up a row of 12 cameras along a whitened stretch of track at Stanford's Palo Alto farm. On June 15, 1878, in front of invited reporters, Stanford's trotter Abe Edgington pulled a sulky across the track at a mile in 2 minutes 20 seconds, its wheel snapping each wire in sequence and firing the cameras roughly 1/1000 of a second apart. A racing mare named Sallie Gardner then ran the same stretch at a pace equivalent to about 1 minute 40 seconds a mile, close to 36 mph, and her saddle girth broke mid-run, visible in the resulting photographs.

The negatives, later published as a card series titled The Horse in Motion, settled the argument. All four of a horse's hooves genuinely do leave the ground at once during a gallop, exactly as Stanford suspected, but not in the extended pose from centuries of paintings. It happens when the legs are gathered underneath the body between strides, a position almost no painter before 1878 had ever depicted. Historian Phillip Prodger has said the popular claim that Stanford had a large bet riding on the outcome is most likely apocryphal, with no primary evidence it ever happened, but the photographic result itself was never in doubt: Muybridge's series became the first example of chronophotography and a direct forerunner of motion pictures.

Why horses switch gaits exactly when they do

Horses don't drift from a walk into a trot at some vague, arbitrary point as they speed up. A 2004 study in the Journal of Experimental Biology, led by Timothy Griffin at the University of Colorado Boulder, put nine horses ranging from 90 to 720 kilograms in body mass and 0.7 to 1.4 meters in leg length on a treadmill and measured both their walk-to-trot transition speed and their oxygen consumption across a wide range of speeds.

Bigger horses switched to a trot at a higher absolute speed than smaller ones did, which sounds obvious on its own. But when Griffin's team converted each horse's transition speed into a Froude number, a dimensionless ratio of speed, leg length, and gravity used to compare gaits across differently sized animals, nearly every horse switched at almost the same value, close to 0.35, regardless of size. That transition point lined up closely with the speed at which trotting stopped costing more oxygen per meter traveled than continuing to walk. A horse doesn't trot because walking becomes physically awkward at higher speeds. It trots the moment trotting becomes the cheaper option, energetically, and every horse in the study made that switch at close to the same value on the same scale. Physics sets hard locomotion limits elsewhere in the animal kingdom too, just from the opposite direction: the same foot-slapping trick that lets a basilisk lizard sprint across open water turns physically impossible for a much heavier animal, a Harvard biomechanics calculation found, because the force needed to keep a bigger body from breaking the surface scales up faster than muscle power can keep up.

How fast the fastest gaits actually go

Average speeds only describe what a horse does most of the time. Under racing conditions, or in a discipline bred specifically for one gait, recorded speeds climb well past the ranges above, though how "fastest ever" gets defined depends on which record-keeping body is doing the timing:

HorseGaitSpeedRecord
First MoonflashGallop44.4 mphAQHA world record, 440 yards in 20.274s, 2009, matched but not beaten by One Famous Jun in 2025
Winning BrewGallop43.71 mphTwo furlongs in 20.57s, 2008, Guinness-certified fastest official race speed
Bulldog HanoverPace34.0 mph1:45.4 mile, 2022 at the Meadowlands, first sub-1:46 pace in harness-racing history
AllegiantTrot33.3 mph1:48.0 mile, 2026 at Solvalla in Sweden, current harness-racing trotting record

The two gallop marks cover the same 440-yard distance but come from different record books: First Moonflash's time is an AQHA world record from specialized Quarter Horse sprint racing, while Winning Brew's is what Guinness World Records certifies as the fastest official racehorse speed under its own verification standard, a genuine case of two different organizations each crowning their own champion over an identical stretch of track. The pace and trot figures, converted here from each horse's official mile time, come from Standardbred horses pulling a two-wheeled sulky rather than carrying a rider, over a full mile rather than a short dash, and both records are recent: Bulldog Hanover's pace fell in 2022, Allegiant's trot only in May 2026, when she became the first mare in 28 years to win Sweden's Elitloppet.

Breeds that move differently

Most breeds share the same four natural gaits and stop there. A handful carry extra gaits that others don't, and a 2012 study in Nature, led by Leif Andersson's group, traced the ability to a single gene: a premature stop codon in DMRT3, nicknamed the 'gait keeper' mutation, found through a genome-wide scan of Icelandic horses and shown in follow-up work to also shape spinal circuit function in mice. Horses carrying the mutation gain access to lateral and ambling gaits that horses without it can't produce naturally, and the same mutation tends to make the transition from trot or pace into a full gallop harder, a genuine tradeoff rather than a pure upgrade.

The Icelandic horse is the clearest example. Alongside the walk, trot, and canter, it naturally performs the tölt, a four-beat lateral gait smooth enough for a rider to sit nearly bounce-free because at least one hoof stays on the ground at every point in the stride, and the flying pace, a two-beat gait with a full suspension phase that can reach around 30 mph over short, straight stretches of 100 to 200 meters and is used specifically in pace racing. Two extra gaits beyond the standard three is why the breed is commonly described as five-gaited.

The American Saddlebred earned the same label through selective breeding rather than a single traceable mutation, adding a collected slow gait and a fast, four-beat rack to the walk, trot, and canter for the show ring. Standardbreds split along a different line entirely: some lines are bred and trained specifically to trot, others specifically to pace, and the two are run as separate careers in harness racing because a horse that excels at one rarely competes well at the other.

Frequently asked questions

What is a horse's gait called?

There's no single name, since it depends on speed. Moving from slowest to fastest, a horse cycles through four names: walk, trot, canter (called a lope under a Western saddle), then gallop. Depending on breed and training, it may also be able to perform an acquired gait such as the pace, the rack, or the tölt.

What are the five gaits of a horse in order?

The breed most associated with that count in U.S. show rings, the Saddlebred, performs them in this sequence: a working walk and trot, a collected canter, a highly collected four-beat stepping pace called the slow gait, and finally the rack, that same lateral footfall performed at speed. Icelandic horses earn a matching count a different way, adding the tölt and flying pace to their own three foundational gaits.

Do all four of a horse's hooves ever leave the ground at once?

Yes, briefly, during the gallop. A California racehorse breeder settled the question with rigged-up cameras back in 1878, and the resulting images overturned a second assumption in the process: all four legs go up together bunched close under the body, not thrown wide apart the way older paintings had always imagined it.

What is the fastest a horse has ever run?

It depends on which organization is keeping the record. AQHA credits First Moonflash with the fastest 440-yard sprint ever run, 20.274 seconds, a mark tied but not beaten since 2009. The record book Guinness maintains instead names the Thoroughbred filly Winning Brew as its own outright fastest racehorse, clocked at 43.71 mph in 2008.

Sources

FC

FactCrumbs Editorial Team

Editorial review